Skip to content

Our testing methodology

How we rate supplements – independent, transparent, with fixed criteria.

How we test

We buy every product ourselves, taste it several times and rate it against four fixed criteria, combined with our community votes. No manufacturer pays us for a better score.

The four rating criteria

CriterionWeightWhat we check
Taste & texture40 %Sweetness, texture, aftertaste – against the flavor description
Price per kg of protein25 %Unit price instead of pack price, so products are truly comparable
Ingredients & nutrition25 %Protein content, sugar, sweeteners, additives, allergens
Availability & trust10 %Stock, price stability, manufacturer transparency

The rating scale

We give scores from 0 to 10 (equivalent to 1–5 stars): 9–10 outstanding, 7–8.9 very good, 5–6.9 solid, below 5 with weaknesses. Every score carries a test date – recipes change, and we document such changes.